England’s Test cricket team today is facing unprecedented levels of scrutiny after performing miserably in the first Test match of the Ashes series against Australia on home turf. The series, which has already seen England’s players struggle to find their form, took a turn for the worse as Australia capitalized on the visitors’ shortcomings.
The match showcased England’s inability to handle the pressure, particularly with the new pink ball, as they failed to restrict Australia’s batters effectively. As it happened – Day three England 334; Australia 204 & 265-6 England 2. Australia responded immediately and scored the runs for the loss of just one wicket with 130 to spare. Both match fitness and lack of awareness were crucial in England’s bowlers stumbling. Not having the ability to string together regular wickets allowed the Australian batsman to run away with the match.
In the past, critics have noted that England doesn’t have the luxury of allowing their best players to start slowly. That’s exactly what unfolded as Australia’s batters teed off on the English attack. Retired Australian captain Ricky Ponting was scathing in his denunciation. He piled further misery on England by terming their bowling performance as “rubbish.”
They’ve been terrible under the new pink ball, England, Ponting continued, emphasizing his team’s inability to do what’s necessary in this fundamental part of the game, reflecting the team’s overall malaise.
As the match wore on, it was clear that England’s bowlers had been undercooked coming into this match. Prior to this, they had only bowled in nets or to a glove. This approach proved insufficient to genuinely replicate the rigors of a real game. Stuart Broad acknowledged this disparity, stating, “There is a big difference between bowling in nets and bowling in matches.”
Broad’s comments point to a worrying lack of preparedness that does not bode well for the Ashes. The players seemed out of match-fitness and from there they didn’t have the match awareness or sharpness to go on to bowl consistently in pressure situations. England’s bowlers were rough with the new soft ball. They just couldn’t land in the right spots with any precision, compounding their issues even further.
According to former Australian cricketer Simon Katich, England failed to take the lessons learnt from their first innings in Perth. “They didn’t learn lessons from the second innings in Perth,” he remarked, highlighting a concerning trend in the team’s approach.
One of the other performances to draw criticism was Jofra Archer’s display. His post-catch body language gave off clear signals of malevolence and desolation. Since a specific over, Archer has not been utilized by captain Ben Stokes, raising questions about his role in the team’s strategy.
Australia raced away in their first innings, reaching 1-130 in reply to England’s score. On this performance, the visitors were left to ponder a complete change in approach ahead of a likely elimination from the contest. That, combined with England’s poor performances with the pink ball and England’s preparation has left the team at a crossroads.

