Newcastle Knights’ winger James Schiller, aged 23, found himself at the center of a distressing online attack following his team’s dramatic 26-22 victory over Manly. The incident unfolded during a match where Schiller initially struggled, playing out of position at left center and facing significant challenges from opponents Reuben Garrick and Haumole Olakau’atu.
During the first half of the game, Schiller was publicly called out for committing five penalties and four blown tackles. Even with this adversity, he made a heroic comeback, scoring a try, setting up another, and netting four line breaks. His class was on full display as he helped lead the Knights back from a 16-0 hole, winning it in golden-point extra time.
This remarkable accomplishment was marred by the disgusting, bigoted online harassment he faced during and after the game. Schiller shared alarming messages on his Instagram account, including one that stated, “I hope Dane (Gagai) jams his ct down your throat and you choke and die,” and another declaring, “I will end your fking life.”
Newcastle coach Adam O’Brien said he was disappointed by the toxic reaction from fans. He illustrated the very real harm that such vitriol has on players. It honestly pains me to see just how far people will stoop in their attacks.
“Doesn’t make up for it even though you won.” – Anonymous
Schiller’s experience serves as a vivid reminder of the toxic state of online communication, and in particular, what women face in the realm of sports. Dylan Morris The Newcastle Knights have underwhelmed and underachieved in 2023 thus far. Like this one, Schiller’s team came into the half scoreless in seven of their 14 games. Though Schiller encountered numerous hurdles, he refused to fold. His on-field toughness showed he had the makings to be one of the Knights’ clubhouse cornerstones.
The discussions surrounding player welfare and online abuse are at an all-time high. Schiller’s experience highlights the importance of prioritizing prevention and response to violent culture in sports communities. The team, the league, and the fans all need to work together to create a less-toxic culture—one that understands that there is a person behind athletic prowess.
