MidCoast gains NSW approval for large-scale coastal retreat
Fewer than 20 homes are vulnerable in the short term, the council says, but several hundred could face erosion risks by 2100.

NSW has certified MidCoast Council’s coastal plan for Old Bar and Manning Point, allowing erosion to proceed without permanent defences for homes. The Department of Climate Change, Energy and Water said it was the state’s first certified plan adopting managed retreat at this scale.
Gerard Tuckerman, the council’s manager of natural systems, said fewer than 20 homes were vulnerable in the short term. Several hundred could be threatened by 2100, he said.
Mr Tuckerman said scientific evidence and community consultation dating from 2008 supported the decision. Residents could use geotextile sandbags to provide temporary protection for their properties.
Old Bar South homeowner Greg Dickson, whose property the council has identified as immediately at risk, wants large-scale sand replenishment instead. He said the prospect of losing homes was stressful for residents, particularly pensioners.
The council considered pumping sand from Farquhar Inlet onto Old Bar Beach in 2010. Mr Tuckerman said that option would then have cost A$147 million, required 1 million cubic metres of sand and needed repeating every decade.
He said engineers rejected a seawall for Old Bar South because it would harm the beach and cost far more than the properties it would protect were worth.
Elsewhere, Port Macquarie-Hastings Council expects certification of its coastal management plans in 2027. Its coast and estuary coordinator, Ben Foster, said retreat was excluded from the current 10-year program but might be needed in the following decade.



